Home > Latest News > Google Set To Appeal The Epic Games Court Ruling

Google Set To Appeal The Epic Games Court Ruling

Google this week is set to appeal a US District Court jury verdict and judge’s ruling in favour of Fortnite developer Epic Games.

Since 2020, Epic Games has sought the right to directly collect in-app payments within Apple’s App Store and Google’s Play Store. It claims both app stores operate as a monopoly which forces Epic to pay 15% and 30% commissions on in-app payments collected during gameplay.

The action has led to a bevy of court cases in the US, along with Federal Court proceedings in Australia, with separate legal action taken against Apple and Google.

Epic eventually lost its case against Apple in 2021 when a judge ruled in Apple’s favour on nine of ten counts. Epic won a minor concession that stops Apple from preventing developers from telling users about the existence of alternative payment methods within their apps. It was case-over when the US Supreme Court denied full appeals by both Apple and Epic in January 2024.

Epic’s court action against Google has soldiered on, with a hearing by a US federal appeals court this week, reports The New York Post.

Epic successfully argued that Google had illegally prevented competition during a San Francisco jury trial in 2023. A judge ordered Google to let users download rival app stores within its Google Play store, an order which is on hold pending this appeal.

Google’s appeal is due to be heard this week in the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco.

Google published a blog post in October 2024 where it detailed its rationale for this appeal.

It partly hinges on the District Court judge having allowed Epic to inform the jurors that Google and Apple are not direct competitors, which Google says is totally wrong.

It also has restated concerns about privacy and security.

“As we have already stated, these changes would put consumers’ privacy and security at risk, make it harder for developers to promote their apps, and reduce competition on devices,” Google says in its blog post.

Google’s key argument that it doesn’t operate a monopoly appears stronger at face value than was Apple’s, as Google allows sideloading of apps outside its Play Store whereas Apple officially does not. But that hasn’t played out in Google’s favour so far.

“These Epic-requested changes stem from a decision that is completely contrary to another court’s rejection of similar claims Epic made against Apple — even though, unlike iOS, Android is an open platform that has always allowed for choice and flexibility like multiple app stores and sideloading.”

Epic, meanwhile, has accused Google of a “years-long strategy to suppress competition among app stores and payment solutions”.

Despite winning its case, Apple hasn’t had it all their way with the European Union’s Digital Markets Act requiring it to allow third party storefronts to be loaded onto iOS devices. The UK is imposing a similar requirement and Epic has said it planned to bring its Epic games store and Fortnite to both jurisdictions.



You may also like
Epic Games Store
Epic Adds Third Party Games To Own Store
Judge Pauses Order Forcing Google To Open App Store To Rivals
Google Play Must Permit Rival Android App Stores
Epic Games Accuses Google And Samsung Of Collaborating To Block Competition
Judge Denies Apple’s Attempt To Slow-walk Epic Case

Popular Posts

EXCLUSIVE: Audio Connection Takes On French Audio Brand, Third Distributor In 4 Years
Latest News
/
/
Hackers on computers wearing face masks. Image: Microsoft Copilot
Urgent Upgrade Of Netgear Routers Recommended
Latest News
/
/
Amazon Struggling To Cope With AI Demand
Latest News
/
/
EXCLUSIVE: Yamaha Responds To Rumours That They Are Set To Quit The AV Market
Latest News
/
/
Apple Settles iPhone 7 ‘Loop Disease’ Lawsuit With US$350m Settlement
Latest News
/
/

Digital Magazines

Recent Post

EXCLUSIVE: Audio Connection Takes On French Audio Brand, Third Distributor In 4 Years
Latest News
/
//
Comments are Off
French audio brand Devialet is on the move again in Australia, this time it’s Audio Connection that is having a...
Read More