The rapid adoption of artificial intelligence in video game development could create an oversupply of low-quality titles, according to veteran game designer Howard Scott Warshaw, who has drawn comparisons with the conditions surrounding the US video game industry crash of 1983.

Speaking at DevGAMM Lisbon 2026, Warshaw warned that AI-powered development tools are making it considerably easier for individuals and smaller studios to produce games, potentially overwhelming consumers with new releases of varying quality.

Warshaw, best known for developing Atari 2600 titles including Yars’ Revenge and E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial, discussed the industry’s changing landscape during a presentation titled From Atari to AI.

He suggested that the increasing accessibility of game development technology resembles the early 1980s, when a surge in poorly received releases contributed to declining consumer confidence in the US gaming market.

The industry subsequently experienced a dramatic downturn, with US video game revenue falling from more than US$3 billion in 1983 to approximately US$100 million by 1985.

Warshaw’s own E.T. game, released in 1982, became closely associated with that period. Developed under an exceptionally tight deadline to reach retailers before Christmas, the title received widespread criticism and became one of the most frequently cited examples of the industry’s problems.

Large quantities of unsold cartridges were subsequently buried in New Mexico, with copies eventually recovered during an excavation decades later.

Despite that history, Warshaw believes the current expansion of AI-generated games presents a different challenge.

He acknowledged that AI tools can substantially reduce the time required to develop software, allowing programming tasks that previously demanded months or years of work to be completed considerably faster.

This increased efficiency is expected to encourage more people to create and publish games, including developers who previously lacked the technical knowledge or resources to bring their ideas to market.

However, Warshaw cautioned that making game development easier does not necessarily improve the quality of the finished product.

Howard Scott Warshaw

He argued that many aspiring creators may now be able to release games that would previously have remained unrealised, potentially increasing the number of unremarkable titles competing for attention.

At the same time, he recognised that AI could provide opportunities for talented developers with innovative concepts who might otherwise struggle to secure funding or technical support.

By reducing programming barriers, the technology could allow smaller teams and independent creators to concentrate more heavily on gameplay, storytelling and design.

Warshaw suggested this shift could ultimately benefit the industry by placing greater emphasis on creativity rather than the technical challenges traditionally associated with game production.

The difficulty, he believes, will be ensuring that worthwhile releases remain visible as the number of available games continues to increase.

Digital distribution platforms such as Steam already face challenges surrounding discoverability, with developers competing for attention in an increasingly crowded marketplace.

AI-assisted development could intensify those pressures by accelerating the volume of new releases.

Nevertheless, Warshaw does not expect the industry to experience another collapse comparable to 1983.

He explained that video games were still regarded by some investors and consumers as a temporary entertainment trend during the early 1980s, making the industry particularly vulnerable when confidence declined.

Today, gaming is firmly established as a major entertainment sector, with audiences spanning consoles, computers, mobile devices and online platforms.

Warshaw believes this widespread adoption makes a comparable market collapse unlikely, although he expects the industry to undergo significant changes as AI becomes more influential.

Rather than disappearing, he suggested the gaming market could reorganise around improved systems for identifying worthwhile content and helping consumers discover innovative titles.

His comments come during a challenging period for the wider games industry, which has experienced substantial restructuring, job losses and changing investment conditions in recent years.

Other prominent industry figures, including Epic Games chief executive Tim Sweeney and Romero Games co-founder Brenda Romero, have also drawn comparisons between current industry conditions and the downturn of the 1980s.

However, Warshaw’s assessment focuses less on the possibility of another financial collapse and more on the consequences of making game production accessible to a much larger number of creators.

While AI could generate an unprecedented volume of new games, he believes the industry’s future success will increasingly depend on its ability to distinguish genuinely engaging experiences from the growing number of competing releases.