There was some good news for Optus this this week despite their latest hack drama, with the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission calling for additional submissions relating to the proposed TPG Telstra deal in regional Australia.
Optus management believe the merger will create a monopoly their view is backed by several expert opinions.
Earlier today the ACCC called for further submissions claiming that they look forward to hearing from stakeholders, the move is a blow to both Telstra and TPG who were confident that the deal would get a go ahead from the competition regulator.
Telstra and TPG are asking the ACCC to provide authorisation for the deemed acquisition of certain TPG spectrum, which is tied to three interrelated network agreements that are being considered together.
Under these agreements, Telstra would obtain much of TPG’s mobile spectrum in a range of outer-suburban and regional areas, where about 17 per cent of Australians live. Telstra would also obtain 169 of TPG’s mobile sites in that area.
TPG would then shut down its remaining 556 mobile sites in those areas and acquire mobile network services from Telstra for mobile coverage.
“The ACCC has today set out issues for further consideration and is calling for further views from industry and consumers on how these agreements may impact competition and whether there are public benefits,” ACCC Commissioner Liza Carver said.
“Mobile companies compete in terms of the infrastructure and spectrum they have, as the infrastructure and spectrum impact on coverage and speed which are important to customers. We are assessing how the proposed infrastructure and spectrum arrangements between TPG, and Telstra will change the incentives and ability of Telstra, TPG, Optus, and other market participants to compete and to invest in mobile service infrastructure.”
“There is still a lot of work to do on this complicated and nuanced review, which is of critical importance to competition in the mobile telecommunication sector. At this stage we have not reached any overall conclusions, but welcome further submissions from stakeholders and consumers alike on the issues raised,” Ms Carver said.
“We are looking extremely closely at all aspects of these agreements, as a decision either way can have significant long-term effects.”
The ACCC can only grant authorisation if it is satisfied in all the circumstances that either there is not a likely substantial lessening of competition, or that there is likely to be public benefits that outweigh any public detriments.
The ACCC’s final decision on whether to grant authorisation to Telstra and TPG will likely be announced in early December.
In general, the ACCC has 90 days to make its decision on applications for merger authorisation, although it can extend the timeframe if the applicants agree. In this case, Telstra and TPG has agreed to an extension, meaning the ACCC now has until 2 December 2022 to make its decision.
Telstra is Australia’s largest mobile network operator, while TPG is the third largest wireless carrier in Australia after Optus.
Telstra operates more than 11,000 mobile base stations nationally while TPG operates more than 5,600. Telstra’s network has 99.5 per cent population coverage, while Optus has 98.5 per cent and TPG has more than 96 per cent, respectively.
Broadly, the arrangement involves TPG authorising Telstra to use spectrum which it currently owns, and Telstra providing TPG with network services by way of active mobile network infrastructure sharing in certain regional and urban fringe areas (the Regional Coverage Zone), which comprise approximately 17 per cent of the Australian population coverage.
TPG would use the MOCN services supplied by Telstra to offer 4G and 5G retail and wholesale services in the Regional Coverage Zone. TPG would also transfer up to 169 of its existing mobile sites in the Regional Coverage Zone to Telstra and intends to decommission the remainder. The initial term of the MOCN Service Agreement is 10 years and TPG has two options to extend the agreement by 5 years.
TPG and Telstra will continue to operate their own networks in metropolitan areas where around 81.4 per cent of Australia’s population resides. TPG and Telstra will also continue to operate their own mobile core networks (both in and outside the Regional Coverage Zone).
